Talking Travel: Perhaps We Spoke Too Soon on E-Channel Travel in China

We almost strained our arms high-fiving ourselves once the new policy that permits foreign holders of residence visas to register and use the e-channel at China Customs checkpoints. We may also have hurt our shoulders punching the air in triumph as we actually used said e-channel upon returning from end-of-year holidays, as we blazed through with a passport scan and a thumbprint, and 300 of our closest friends sucked it up in the usual serpentine immigration line. 

All along we suspected that this might be too good to be true, and in at least a few cases, it has proved that it is.

The ability to use the e-channel even some of the time is preferable to not using it ever, but the sinking feeling when one is directed back into the immigration Trail of Tears and filling out that sad, yellow form is a bitter pill to swallow when you were expecting the express treatment.

Your writer tasted this bitterness while flying to Hong Kong last week. That charming dusting of snow we received in the small hours of Thursday, January 19, turned what should have been an easy commute to Hong Kong into a 30-hour race against the clock thanks to icy roads and the numerous accidents they caused.

Re-routed via Kunming, this meant a domestic flight to the Yunnan capital followed by customs clearance and immigration procedures in Kunming. Smugly, I strolled to the e-channel, only to be told, twice, by an immigration official that it was closed, and was shown to the line for the rest of humanity. It wasn't closed only to me. While the lights were on and it would have appeared otherwise operational, a barrier had been placed in front of it for no apparent reason. 

Another Beijinger editor was refused use of the e-channel at Terminal 2 in Beijing because his/her international airline was "not registered" for e-channel passenger use, which of course makes absolutely no sense – registration is done with China Customs and has nothing to do with the airline being flown. Sense or no sense, he/she too was sentenced to The Line.

However, said editor used e-channel upon returning to Beijing with no hiccups, and I was able to use it inbound upon arrival at Guangzhou Train Station, the first land-based test of the system in our ad hoc focus group. We continue to recommend the e-channel as a nice benefit of having a residence visa. However, don't assume that it – and the time savings that may be derived – are automatic, and continue to arrive at least two hours in advance for international air travel.

Speaking of allotting time: if you're reading this shortly before heading to the airport to begin Spring Festival celebrations, add at least one hour to normal arrival times. That means three hours before an international flight, two hours before a domestic connection. Check-in and security lines are at the longest point of the year, and everyone else is in the same boat as you.

Charge your devices, bring something lightweight or disposable to read, and take a deep breath. Just because we live here doesn't mean it isn't still the world's largest annual migration of people on the planet. 

We'll revisit why China Eastern is the nation's worst carrier and how sucky websites are now costing airlines money and passengers in an upcoming edition of Talking Travel. Until then, we wish you the flattest and safest of roads on your Spring Festival journey.

More stories by this author here.

Email: stevenschwankert@thebeijinger.com
Twitter: @greatwriteshark
Weibo:​ @SinoScuba潜水

Photo: Steven Schwankert/the Beijinger

Comments

New comments are displayed first.

Sad but true. I'm sorry to hear that. 

As an update, I used the e-channel successfully during Spring Festival both entering and departing via Guangzhou, taking the train from and to Hong Kong, and at Terminal 2. So far, it works more than it hasn't.

Thank you all for sharing your experiences and comments. Clearly, the system is a work in progress and each person's mileage seems to vary.

I would say that if we get to use e-channel some of the time, it's better than never using it. Of course, that's not really acceptable for what should be a national program where the experience should be exactly the same regardless of location or mode of transport, but it's better than always waiting in the line. 

There is always the option to go through the conventional line to receive a stamp. Anyone with a visa renewal or new household regulation coming up within 30 days, probably more like 60, should forego entering via the e-channel to receive the appropriate stamp. Mafan amidst convenience.

My own recent experience with e-channel has been interesting. I entered Zhuhai from Macao this month and the agent informed me that I was eligible to register for e-channel (I have a work permit). I asked her if I could do it there (at Gongbei) and she said no, I would have to do it at the place where my visa was issued (Beijing). I don't know how accurate that information is, but I didn't push the issue. Nice to mention it, I guess.

Later this month I took the overnight train from Kowloon to Beijing West. At immigration I asked the agent whether I could apply for e-channel there and she said only with a permanent residence permit (green card). I said that I had heard that work permits were now accepted. She replied that maybe the airport would accept it but not the train station. Once again I didn't ask the manager (something about those places makes me want to get out as soon as possible).

So there are two things to think about. I think there's a good chance that I was given incorrect information (imagine that) and might have gotten a different answer from the manager, but it might be partially true. You never really know.

Wow, I had not thought about that. You're right that they do check that stamp on certain occasions. When you get an extension of a residence permit or visa in Beijing, you don't get a new stamp (of course), and they seem to just check the last stamp you have. I wonder if it would be an issue if you were being marked as having entered (for example) October 2016 when you had actually left and reentered the country in January 2017. Definitely needs some investigation.

But it doesn't seem to be a dealbreaker because as Steven Schwankert commented in the last article on this,

Quote:
If you require a visa stamp or record of entry for some reason, like a visa renewal, then you may need to go to the duty desk and ask them to print one for you.

Still I would prefer the stamp - that tiny piece of paper that they give you in Hong Kong is so easy to lose (not sure what the mainland one looks like)

One of the problems with the echannel is that you don't have a stamp in your passport and so while it may make your airport experience easier and faster to go through the echannel, there are many aspects of life in China that we still need to prove that entry stamp, such as local police regristration for the temporary certrificate (when renting / moving an apartment, etc); at the bank for certain transactions; at a hotel, etc. A Chinese friend indicated that an application at the Public Security Bureau Entry and Exit division is required if you then later want to obtain the stamp for some reason.